Southlake's Best Pies [Updated 2025]

Let me tell you, pie lovers, my taste buds have been on a delicious adventure! After diving into 12 of the top pie spots in Southlake, I’ve uncovered some sweet surprises and savory delights that will make your mouth water.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve savored every bite, dissected flavors, and chatted with passionate bakers who pour their hearts into every crust. Whether you're a fan of classic apple or looking for a creative twist, there’s something for everyone in this charming town. So, grab your fork and get ready to indulge in the ultimate pie experience—Southlake style!

Oak Street Pie Company

Highlights
Good customer service
Great buttermilk pie
Longtime loyal customers
Quality flavor experience
Limited pie options available

Oak Street Pie Company has captured the hearts of many with its inviting ambiance and scrumptious offerings. Upon stepping inside, the warm aromas envelop you like a cozy hug, setting the stage for a delightful experience. The customer service is as wonderful as the pies themselves; the staff greets you with genuine smiles, eager to help you navigate through the selection.

Now, let’s talk about the buttermilk pie—a true standout. It boasts a silky smooth texture with just the right balance of sweetness and tang, leaving you with a satisfied smile after each bite. It’s no wonder they have a host of loyal customers returning for their cravings! The flavor experience is remarkably enchanting; every slice sings with nostalgia, reminding you of cherished family gatherings.

However, I did notice a slight drawback—limited pie options available. While the few offerings are delectable, I yearn for a broader variety to indulge in. Still, Oak Street’s commitment to quality shines through, making it a top contender on my pie journey through Southlake. If you're in the mood for a classic slice of heaven, this is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Fort Worth.

JudyPie

Highlights
Flaky, crispy pie crust
Exceptional pecan pie
Delightful raspberry lemon hand pie
Rich, creamy chocolate pie
Balanced apple pie flavors

JudyPie in Southlake is a delightful little gem for pie lovers. As soon as I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly baked pastries enveloped me like a warm hug. I couldn’t resist trying their signature pecan pie, and let me tell you, it was a revelation! The flaky, crispy crust was the perfect foundation for the rich, nutty filling, creating a harmonious balance of flavors that left me craving another slice.

But the pecan pie wasn’t the only star of the show. The raspberry lemon hand pie took me by surprise with its delightful tanginess—sweet yet refreshing. I found myself savoring each bite of its delicate crust, which was soft yet sturdy enough to hold the luscious filling.

Not to be overlooked, the rich, creamy chocolate pie was a chocolate lover's dream, while the apple pie boasted just the right balance of spices and sweetness, reminiscent of a classic homemade version.

In a town where pie-making is an art form, JudyPie stands out as a must-visit destination. If you're wandering Southlake and yearning for a slice of happiness, this is the place to be—where every bite takes you to pie paradise!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Grapevine.

Cookie Society-Southlake

Highlights
Unique Monthly Flavors
Great for Sweet Tooth Lovers
Friendly and Helpful Staff
Fun Family Visit Destination
Consistent Cookie Quality

Cookie Society-Southlake is quite the culinary paradise for anyone with a sweet tooth! While typically known for their delectable cookies, I was curious to see how their pie offerings stacked up. Upon entering, I was instantly greeted by friendly and helpful staff who made me feel right at home, inviting me to explore their unique monthly flavors. One standout flavor that caught my eye was the Peach Crumble Pie, bursting with fresh, fruity goodness and a buttery, flaky crust that crumbled just right.

Each bite was a delight, showcasing the consistent quality that Cookie Society is known for. It's the perfect spot for a fun family visit, as there are enough flavors to satisfy everyone, from classic to their adventurous seasonal selections. The ambiance radiated a warm, inviting energy that made it easy to savor my pie while observing families indulge in cookies, creating a nostalgic and wholesome atmosphere.

If you find yourself in Southlake in search of a slice of something sweet, don’t overlook Cookie Society. It’s a joyful experience that will leave you yearning for more. Their imaginative desserts truly elevate the pie game within the region!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Arlington.

BreadHaus

Highlights
Super friendly vibes
Divine fresh baked goods
Must-visit early for best options
Welcoming and knowledgeable staff
Open kitchen for viewing

BreadHaus: A Slice of Heaven in Southlake

Stepping into BreadHaus is like entering a cozy bakery wonderland. The welcoming and knowledgeable staff instantly make you feel at home, ready to help you navigate the delicious offerings. I was captivated by the open kitchen where I watched bakers craft exquisite pastries and pies, all while a comforting warmth enveloped the space.

As I perused the menu, it became clear that these pies are not just desserts; they are handcrafted art. The first bite of their signature pie was a revelation—flaky, buttery crust embracing a rich, seasonal filling that danced on my palate. It was no surprise to learn that arriving early is key to snagging the best selections; the divine fresh baked goods fly off the shelves as quickly as they come out of the oven!

If you’re a pie enthusiast, consider BreadHaus a must-visit destination. The inviting atmosphere combined with the joyful energy makes every moment spent there delightful. I left not just with a pie, but with an experience that I can't wait to relive. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best new york style pizza in Fort Worth.

Pinch of Salt Pastries & Coffee

Highlights
Best gluten-free bakery
Friendly and accommodating staff
Exceptional flavor in pastries
Popular for special events
Must-try raspberry pound cake

When it comes to the best pies in Southlake, my visit to Pinch of Salt Pastries & Coffee was a delightful revelation. Touted as the best gluten-free bakery in the area, this charming spot specializes in pastries that are not only accommodating for dietary restrictions but bursting with flavor.

As I entered, the friendly and accommodating staff instantly made me feel at home. Their enthusiasm for the art of baking was evident as they shared the story behind their signature creations. I savored a slice of their exquisite pie, which boasted an incredible balance of sweetness and tartness, leaving my taste buds dancing with joy.

Pairing the pie with a warm cup of coffee created a heavenly experience that felt lovingly crafted. Beyond their pies, I couldn't help but notice the chatter among other customers about their must-try raspberry pound cake, an indication of their loyal following for special events. Each bite transported me to dessert paradise.

With its inviting atmosphere and exceptional flavors, Pinch of Salt is undoubtedly a top contender on my quest for the best pie in town. I simply can’t wait to return and try more of their delightful offerings!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Fort Worth.

Sweet Lucy's Pies

Highlights
Mini bite-sized pies
Outstanding flaky crust
Custom order options
Delicious seasonal flavors
Exceptional customer service

Let me tell you, Sweet Lucy's Pies is a delightful gem nestled in Southlake, where each visit is like stepping into a pie lover's paradise. As I walked in, the outstanding flaky crusts caught my eye, promising the perfect balance of crunch and tenderness. I couldn't resist diving into their mini bite-sized pies, which are not only adorable but also bursting with flavor—ideal for when you're torn between choices!

I was particularly enamored with their delicious seasonal flavors. From savory pumpkin to tangy key lime, each pie evokes the spirit of the season, making every visit a new adventure for my taste buds. The best part? They offer custom order options, so whether you need a pie to celebrate a special occasion or just want to indulge, they’ve got you covered.

What truly sets Sweet Lucy’s apart is their exceptional customer service. The staff is as warm and inviting as the pies they serve, making you feel right at home. Overall, Sweet Lucy’s Pies is a must-visit for anyone craving a slice of happiness in Southlake. Their pies are not just desserts; they are an experience worth savoring!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Arlington.

Everett & Elaine

Highlights
Delicious cherry filling
Irresistible cinnamon bun
Excellent seasonal pies
Superb lemon meringue crust
Helpful and patient staff

When it comes to pie, Everett & Elaine in Southlake is a delightful treasure trove that I simply couldn't resist exploring. The moment I walked in, the aroma of fresh-baked goodness enveloped me like a warm hug. I dove straight into their irresistible cherry pie, and let me tell you, the filling was a perfect balance of sweet and tart, making each bite a burst of happiness.

But the highlight didn’t stop there! I savored one of their superb lemon meringue pies; the crust was so flaky and delicate, it practically melted in my mouth. The lemon filling had just the right zing to make my taste buds dance with joy.

I also had the pleasure of trying their cinnamon bun pie, which was a heavenly mashup that felt like a warm cinnamon hug on a plate. The staff at Everett & Elaine were exceptionally helpful and patient, guiding me through my scrumptious selections and indulging my curiosity about their seasonal offerings.

In the world of Southlake pies, Everett & Elaine shines brightly, affirming that this charming spot is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth!

You might also want to check out the best burger in Fort Worth.

Texas Harvest Pie Company [Phone Orders Only]

When it comes to pies in Southlake, Texas Harvest Pie Company is a true gem. Their phone-order system might seem quirky, but the results are heavenly! I indulged in their seasonal peach pie, which boasted a flaky, golden crust and sweet, juicy filling. Each bite was a delightful dance of flavors. The care they put into sourcing local ingredients really shines through. Though I had to order over the phone, the friendly service made it feel warm and inviting. If you’re a pie enthusiast, don’t miss out on this slice of heaven—a true celebration of Texas flavors!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Fort Worth.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Flower Mound

With a whimsical charm that instantly draws you in, Buttermilk Sky Pie Flower Mound offers an exquisite array of pies that are simply delightful. I couldn’t resist trying their signature buttermilk pie, a velvety masterpiece that dances on the palate with hints of cinnamon and vanilla. Each slice is a reminder of home-baked goodness, evoking the warm embrace of family gatherings. The crust is perfectly flaky, creating a harmonious balance with the creamy filling. Service is friendly and inviting, making it a slice of heaven in Southlake. For pie lovers, this gem is a must-visit to indulge your sweet cravings!

You might also want to check out the best chicken fried steak in Fort Worth.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Upon stepping into Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, I was greeted by the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pies that instantly sparked joy. Their signature Buttermilk Pie, creamy and perfectly balanced with a hint of nutmeg, is a must-try. Each slice melts in your mouth, making it a delightful choice. The cozy atmosphere adds a lovely touch, inviting you to savor every bite. Don’t miss their fruit pies, bursting with seasonal flavors. Overall, this charming shop has captured my heart and taste buds, earning a top spot on my list of the best pies in Southlake. Heavenly indeed!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Colleyville.

D'CARAMEL PATISSERIE

Tucked away in the heart of Southlake, D'CARAMEL PATISSERIE is a delightful haven for pie enthusiasts. The moment I stepped inside, the sweet aroma enveloped me like a warm hug. I indulged in their signature caramel pecan pie, and let me tell you, each bite was a perfect balance of sweetness and crunch. The crust was buttery and flaky, complementing the rich filling beautifully. The decor adds a charming touch, making it an inviting spot to savor these treats. If you're on the hunt for a slice of heaven, D'CARAMEL is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best dessert in Fort Worth.

Cake Pops by Alli

At Cake Pops by Alli, I discovered a delightful twist on traditional desserts — their mini pies pack a surprising punch! These little wonders come in various flavors, each boasting a flaky, buttery crust that crumbles perfectly upon the first bite. I savored the classic apple pie, which had just the right amount of cinnamon and sweetness. The customer service was as delightful as the treats, with Alli herself sharing the inspiration behind each recipe. If you’re on the hunt for a charming spot to satisfy your pie cravings, Cake Pops by Alli is a must-visit! 🍏🥧

You might also want to check out the best food in Grapevine.